When Jaén's Picual stopped being «cat pee»

For decades, Italians called the olive oil from Jaén «cat pee». Marino Uceda proved that the defect lay not in the Picual olive but in how it was harvested and milled. In 1988, a well-made Picual baffled Mario Solinas, the great master of tasters.

By 9 min read

Marino Uceda, investigador del aceite picual de Jaén, en su casa
In this article

    In Italy they used to call the oil from Jaén «pipí de gato», cat pee, and they had their reasons. Picual olive oils did not have a genetic problem; they had a harvesting and milling problem. It was proven by Marino Uceda, an engineer they called crazy for talking about quality when the only thing that mattered was kilos. Today that oil wins competitions.

    For decades, Picual oil from Jaén had a reputation for being defective because the olives were harvested late, piled up for days and paid at the same price whether the oil was good or bad. Marino proved that the defect came from the process, not from the olive. In 1988 a well-made Picual baffled Mario Solinas, the great master of tasters at the International Olive Council. Ten years later the University of Jaén launched its expert course in virgin olive oil tasting.

    Why Picual had a reputation as «cat pee»

    Picual olives had a bad name because they reached the mill bruised and fermented, not because they were Picual.

    Jaén has more than 550,000 hectares of olive groves and, depending on the year, produces around a fifth of the world's olive oil. Almost all of it is Picual. On paper the variety has it all: it yields a lot, gives a lot of oil and keeps well. And yet the handbooks of the 1970s and 80s rated its oil as medium-to-low quality.

    Marino Uceda, the spiritual (and partly biological) father of Molino & Cata, a doctor in agricultural engineering and a researcher at the Jaén Olive Growing Station, didn't buy it. «This is not possible», he remembers thinking, «because the glyceride structure of Picual was marvellous». He suspected something else: the problem lay in ripening, harvesting and processing.

    At the Olive Growing and Oil Technology Station (now IFAPA in Mengíbar) they measured it with a penetrometer. As the Picual olive turns from veraison to black, its flesh becomes far less firm. If it is also knocked about and left waiting, it ferments. That is where the unmistakable smell of dirty fig leaf, or cat pee, comes from.

    If everything is paid the same, you mill for volume, not quality

    Under Franco and in the first years of the transition to democracy, nobody cared about quality, because the price of olive oil was set by the State. For decades it was a staple with a regulated price.

    So the olives were stockpiled: piled up in heaps, called «trojes», for days or weeks waiting their turn. «What you had to do was mill as many kilos as possible», says Marino. «And so a lot of lampante came out». Lampante is oil that cannot be eaten until it has been through a refinery.

    When the price of olive oil shot up in 1963, the State looked for a shortcut. The Ministry of Commerce itself commissioned adverts on Spanish state television: olive oil and sunflower oil were poured into the frying pan together, mixed, to make it cheaper. Olive growers took to the streets. The message a whole country received was that olive oil was an expense worth cutting.

    The next time someone tells you that Spanish consumers «don't appreciate» olive oil, remind them that for years public television taught them the opposite.

    «The crazy engineer from Madrid»

    Talking about quality in the 1970s made you an eccentric. Marino started doing it in 1974 and 1975, and earned himself a nickname: «the crazy engineer from Madrid». In 1980 he wrote in the magazine Agricultura, issue 572, that the answer to the olive sector's problems could come from quality. «And I still believe it», he says today, 46 years later.

    Marino Uceda's article in the magazine Agricultura, 1980: How to obtain quality olive oil
    «Cómo obtener aceite de calidad» (How to obtain quality olive oil), by Marino Uceda and Luisa Frías. «Agricultura», no. 572, January 1980. Library of the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food.

    In Mora de Toledo he gave a talk in a theatre packed with between 300 and 500 people. At the end someone asked the question everyone had in mind: why do the Italians take our oil and sell it for more? «Because they're smarter than we are», he answered. He was booed.

    But the full answer was not an insult, it was a diagnosis. Italy had spent years on marketing and positioning, work nobody was going to hand to Jaén for free. And his conclusion still holds: «Today a lot of oil is still sold in bulk, and I think that is the main mistake, because the added value stays somewhere else». If you want to see what happens to prices when the value goes elsewhere, we explain it in the downward pressure on olive oil prices at origin.

    Uceda Ojeda and Uceda Leal

    The story has a second protagonist: Ángel Uceda Leal, Marino's father. He owned an olive mill in Jaén and was a lawyer, although he never practised. He was asked to turn the Regulatory Warehouses, where oil was stored in surplus years, into a public-law body. He wrote its statutes, and in December 1979 a royal decree gave it shape: the Patrimonio Comunal Olivarero.

    On 4 July 1984 the Official State Gazette published another advertising campaign. This time it was not about diluting olive oil with sunflower oil, but about getting Spain to consume more olive oil, with a budget of almost 50 million pesetas. It was signed by the managing director: Ángel Uceda Leal.

    One wanted the country to buy olive oil. The other, for it to be worth buying. Despite his contribution, when the Patrimonio celebrated the centenary of its creation, they did not see fit to invite his son.

    Mario Solinas and Picual from Jaén

    The proof came in a glass. In 1988, at Venta del Llano (Jaén), Marino served an oil to his former tasting teacher: Mario Solinas, an Italian chemist at the International Olive Council and, together with Rafael Gutiérrez González-Quijano, one of the key figures behind the first scientific method for tasting olive oil. Today the IOC's top quality award bears his name; we explain it in our article on the Mario Solinas award.

    Blue tasting glass with Picual extra virgin olive oil
    The tasting glass is blue so that the oil's colour does not influence the taster.

    Solinas knew Jaén held a world collection of olive varieties, so he started guessing. A Frantoio? No. A Hojiblanca? No. It was Picual.

    Green oil

    It was a Picual oil, made from olives picked at their optimum moment and milled properly. Marino is blunt about this: «Green is an adjective that means nothing». Some oils that are not green are extremely powerful, and some green oils are not, because intensity depends on phenols, not chlorophyll. What he looks for is something else: an oil that is «harmonious, balanced, powerful, with great fruitiness, with its bitterness and its pungency, within a harmony». In other words, colour tells you nothing.

    Today, as Marino says, it is rare to look at the top fifteen oils in any ranking and not find three or four Picuals.

    Chemically extra virgin, but not in the glass

    Convincing Solinas didn't take much. The great master knew a good extra virgin olive oil when he tasted one. Convincing the sector took longer. In the late 1990s a committee of experts took samples from 240 olive mills: on the tree, on arrival at the mill and after malaxation. The heaps and the old pressing mats were gone, and in the laboratory almost everything came out extra virgin. But once sensory analysis was added, the result collapsed: between 40 and 50% of those oils were no longer extra virgin.

    Mercedes, Marino's daughter, sums it up like this: «Olive oil is the only food whose commercial category depends on a sensory analysis». Organoleptic assessment has been mandatory in the European Union since Regulation (EEC) 2568/91, and for an oil to be extra virgin the median of defects must be zero. As Mercedes explains, «a single defect, however slight, and the oil drops a category no matter how good the chemistry is». We go into it in detail in what extra virgin really means.

    The underlying problem was cultural. Some people in the sector were convinced that a very bitter oil was a defective oil. People had to be taught to taste, and in 1998 Marino and other experts launched a 300-hour tasting course at the University of Jaén, which this year celebrates its 23rd edition. If you want to know what is taught there, start with our guide on how to taste olive oil.

    From harvesting too late to harvesting too early

    Marino's lesson is not «the earlier, the better». In some villages the harvest used to start after Epiphany; the norm was to start after the Feast of the Immaculate Conception in early December. «Now they're starting at the end of September», he warns, «which is another huge mistake. You have to give biology its time». An oil can change in a single week.

    He had already written it in 1980: harvest when most of the green fruit has disappeared from the tree. It is the same idea we defend in our article on early harvest olive oil: early does not mean green at any cost, it means at the right point and milled the same day.

    What remains of all this

    Marino has spent his life translating scientific studies that only a handful of people read so that they reach the people working in the groves and the mills. «I've written thirty-odd books», he says, laughing, «but not even my own father knows who I am». Until we published a video of him tasting oil and it went viral.

    His father, Ángel, had an olive mill in Beas de Segura, Industria Santa Isabel, with a single rule: no fraud was ever committed in that house. What was the trick others used? Marino smiles and doesn't tell.

    No label will ever tell you this. A glass will. Come to one of our tastings at the shop, try several Picuals side by side and compare. Or choose one of our premium extra virgin olive oils and do the test at home. «Cat pee» no longer exists in Jaén. What exists is oil that someone took the trouble to make well.

    Frequently asked questions

    Why was Picual from Jaén called «cat pee»?

    Because of a processing defect, not a flaw in the variety. Ripe Picual olives have soft flesh; if they are bruised and piled up for days before milling, they ferment and give off a characteristic smell that Italian tasters associated with Jaén. Harvested at the right moment and milled quickly, Picual produces some of the most highly rated oils in the world.

    Who is Marino Uceda?

    Marino Uceda is a doctor in agricultural engineering, former principal investigator and former head of the tasting panel at IFAPA, and a consultant to the FAO. Since the 1970s he has argued that the future of olive growing lies in quality, and in 1998 he helped launch the tasting course at the University of Jaén. He is Mercedes Uceda's father and the scientific adviser to Molino y Cata.

    Since when has tasting been mandatory to classify olive oil?

    In the European Union, since Regulation (EEC) 2568/91, which added organoleptic assessment to the official classification. A panel of 8 to 12 trained tasters decides whether an oil is extra virgin, virgin or lampante. To be extra virgin, the median of defects must be zero and the median of fruitiness greater than zero.

    Is a greener oil a better oil?

    No. Colour depends on chlorophyll and carotenoids, while intensity and bitterness depend on polyphenols. That is why official tastings use a dark glass: so that colour does not influence the score. A yellow oil can be extremely powerful and a very green one flat.

    Jerónimo Palacios

    Co-founder of Molino & Cata. He runs the business, the online shop, distribution to restaurants and hotels, and marketing for extra virgin olive oil producers.

    More about Jerónimo